James S. Russell

Architecture Critic, Journalist and Consultant

  • Blog
  • About
  • Consulting
  • Journalism
  • Contact
  • Blog
  • About
  • Consulting
  • Journalism
  • Contact

NY Times “Invisible Child” Is Not a Victim of Inequality

by James Russell on December 13, 2013 - Get free updates on posts here

If you have not read the “Invisible Child” series in the New York Times (http://www.nytimes.com/projects/2013/invisible-child/#/?chapt=1), you will find the story of a plucky child, Dasani, heartbreaking and riveting. She lives with her siblings in a homeless shelter  It is exquisitely written by Andrea Elliott.

I wish Elliott had not framed her story with income inequality. Throughout, the story contrasts the enormous challenges and deprivations faced by Dasani (yes, she is named after the bottled water) with the signs of affluence in rapidly gentrifying Fort Greene, Brooklyn. The idea of inequality smothers rather than reveals why Dasani’s world is so painfully difficult.

Dasani, who stands in line for more than an hour for the chance to microwave a premade meal, can barely comprehend an upscale donut shop or specialty wine store. But without the great wealth the city has created over the last decade or so she would not go to a school good enough that she could consider it a refuge. She is able to practice pull-ups in a park that is at least in good repair and safe to use.

In North Philadelphia, amid streets far more battered than any in New York, I recently saw several libraries — all closed and as derelict as the blocks surrounding them. I passed a school I thought was abandoned, but then saw kids pouring out of it. The system has suffered draconian cuts and is trying to avert a death spiral.

Horrific as their lives are, Dasani and her family would have even fewer chances in most any American city or suburb that has a significant population of poor people. There’s been no serious engagement with issues of poverty since the 1970s. The Great Recession showed how broken our housing-finance system is, yet almost nothing got fixed. Dasani’s grandmother, one of the few stable influences in her life, loses her home to foreclosure and herself may become homeless. It is one of the reasons homelessness has exploded in New York and elsewhere.

Gentrification, seen in the series as an enemy, should bring the possibility of jobs and opportunity to families like Dasani’s. There are not policies in place to protect the low-income people who keep poor communities intact through the bad times, so they become victims, taxed out or priced out. Only a fraction of renters paying half or more of their income in rent (a punishing necessity in high-cost cities) can get exceedingly rare housing subsidies.

By contrast the federal tax code richly rewards owners (especially in high-income cities like New York) with deductions for mortgages and real-estate taxes that can cover a third of housing costs. That pushes prices up.

Cities cannot afford to spurn the wealthy because no one else is going to pay the bills. Philadelphia wishes it had more rich people. One urban expert several years ago made a list of cities that had become wealthy enough to “kick out” the poor. Never discussed openly, it is a practical necessity, however cruel, because poor people are a liability. Even New York in an era of extraordinary wealth cannot house its needy population alone. The Federal government at best offers almost no housing help (though New York gets much more than most), stingy food stamps, and stigmatizing welfare (though not, apparently, for Dasani’s family). There’s almost no focus on a route out of poverty for people and communities. Many states wash their hands.

Inequality registers most powerfully in real-estate costs, which have risen with startling speed in New York and affect people far up the income spectrum as well as those at the bottom. But it’s far from the whole story.

Filed Under: Architecture

Comments

  1. Serena says

    February 28, 2015 at 3:41 pm

    Hello admin, your page is incredible i know very useful tool for every site admin (for content creation and SEO).
    Just search in google for:
    Stoonkel’s Rewriter

    Reply
  2. Lorenza says

    October 2, 2016 at 10:26 pm

    If you are interested in topic: how to earn fast money in gta 5
    online ps3 – you should read about Bucksflooder first

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Buy This Book

About James Russell

James S. Russell is an architecture critic, journalist, teacher and consultant. He's the author of the book, The Agile City, and has written for publications like Architectural Record, Bloomberg News, NY Times and more. Continue reading

Recent Posts

  • Cities’ rise from the dead shows why extortion is bad
  • It Should Not Be Bad for Cities to be Rich
  • Can Amazon Be . . . Gasp . . . Good for New York?
  • Questions for Brett Kavanaugh
  • Tax Plan to Cities: Drop Dead

Hire me to speak

I frequently speak to groups on architecture, urban growth trends, and architectural responses to climate change. If you are interested in having me participate in your event, check out some previous events I’ve spoken at

Search

Subscribe

Even if you don't visit the site often, you can get the latest posts delivered to you free via email. I will not share or sell your email.

Follow me on Twitter | Facebook | LinkedIn